is, in The Old Cobbler’s opinion, the best effort to date in the series. Reading the book left me with the thought that the development of the Brady Coyne character has a lot in common with Gordon & MacPhail’s Dallas Dhu 24-year old Single Malt Scotch.The first book in this series, DEATH AT CHARITY’S POINT, was released in 1984. Tapply has written 23 more books in the series⎯one book every year since Ronald Reagan was re-elected President, and Apple introduced the Macintosh computer with the now famous television commercial.
These 24 years of Tapply’s devotion to developing the series and its main character
has produced a finished story that approaches the reader’s palate with a subtlety and complexity that puts it on the level of the single malt scotch.Part of this subtlety is in the way Tapply paints word pictures, far different from some of his peers. James Lee Burke inserts vast, detailed landscape murals into his story lines. He does an excellent job. They make you want to pull off the road, stop, and look around for a while. Tapply accomplishes the same goal with only a few words.
One example: Brady Coyne is driving out of Boston to see a client. “It was another postcard New England autumn day. The maples and oaks along the Esplanade glowed in shades of gold and orange, and the sun glittered off the Charles River.” The reader gets the picture without slowing down.
The book’s opening is a simple one, belying what comes later. Brady is in his office. It’s late afternoon. He’ sitting and looking out the window. “The low-angled late-afternoon October sun was washing the tops of the Trinity Church and the Copley Plaza Hotel with warm orange light, and dusk was beginning to seep into the floor of the city.”
A visitor arrives in his office unannounced. A former lady friend, Alexandria Shaw, walks back into his life after seven years. She wants him to help her older brother who has been kicked out of his house by his wife who has filed for divorce.
This older brother was a photojournalist, freelancing in Iraq where he lost his right hand, came home with post-traumatic stress disorder and a totally screwed-up outlook on life. Waving a pistol in his family’s face had been the final act that bought him his one-way ticket out the door.
Brady agrees to take the case, if the brother wants representation. When the brother accepts, Brady is happy. That means he and his former lady friend will be seeing more of each other, which may be a good thing. Brady’s not certain.
His uncertainty stems from the fact that his last lady friend, Evie Banyon, had co-habituated with him in his townhouse until leaving four months earlier to tend to a dying father in California. Since her leaving, the two have not run up large phone bills. Brady is beginning to have questions.
His questions are answered a few days later when he receives a letter from Evie. She doesn’t mess around with any off-speed pitches in the letter. Her Dear John message is like a fastball from Pedro Martinez on the mound at Fenway Park. It’s down the middle of the plate, heart-high, for a called third strike, the last out of the game. Coyne doesn’t argue the call with the ump. He tries to put the game out his mind.
Alex is back in his life, old flames are rekindled, and Brady still has his two most ardent and dependable supporters. He has an obedient canine, a Brittany named Henry David Thoreau, and Julie, his secretary and the secret weapon that keeps her boss on the list of Boston’s well-paid lawyers. That does not mean a chorus is going to break into song, with a melodic rendering of “Autumn in New England.”
This is a Brady Coyne novel. As we who are regular readers have come to know there’s a big shoe out there, ready to drop. This is Brady Coyne. His stumbling into troublesome situations is more of a frequent problem than is his stumbling through relationships with women.
The serenity and tranquility of the New England autumn is shattered when Alex’s brother is found dead in his apartment, a gun shot to the head. The official ruling is suicide. But Alex does not agree. She says her brother would not kill himself, and asks Brady to help find out what really happened. He agrees, not that he fully shares her doubts, but sees it as a way to keep their renewed relationship going.
From this point, the story takes on the quality of the bottle of Dallas Dhu Single Malt. On the surface it’s a story of lawyer Brady talking to people, many of them war veterans, asking them questions, getting pieces of answers.
Brady receives a phone call from a man who speaks in what seems to be code. The man promises to call again. But he is murdered before he can call. This brings in Brady’s long-time friend from the state police, Inspector Roger Horowitz.
And the FBI shows up. In his sleuthing, Brady has unknowingly met a man wanted on federal charges for blowing up buildings back in the 1970s. The bomber had gone underground, changed his name, and the feds’ last picture of the man is over three decades old.
Brady helps develop an up-to-date image of the man he saw, which confirms it’s the wanted bomber. Collectively, the good guys guess correctly as to what the bomber’s next target will be and prevent the second shot heard round the world.
But underneath these daily events of murder and mayhem, the reader sees, through Brady’s eyes, a subtler, more complex side effect of war. He meets former soldiers and civilians, who have been scared mentally as well as physically, some in Iraq, others as far back as Vietnam. Many of them are misunderstood, except within their mutual support groups.
Some of these mental scars have warped logical thought, leading to illogical decisions as to how feelings about war should be expressed, how far actions can be taken to express these feelings. And Brady learned that at least one individual had a rather complex idea as to who should die and who should live. He remained alive to learn this truth.
It’s a story that also makes it clear that drastic actions are sometimes necessary to stop desperate individuals who have lost all sense of the value of life, both for themselves and anyone else in range of their planned violence.
And it’s a story in which Brady begins to ask himself questions regarding his relationships with women, and begins to maybe see some answers. But this does not mean he will stop playing the game; taking his turn at the plate, ready to swing at the right pitch.
Tapply’s photo in this post was taken by his wife Vicki Stiefel, also an award-winning author and very accomplished photographer.


